Kraftmaid vs RTA (barkers, Scherrs)

bichonloverMarch 2, 2013

My venture to update my kitchen keeps taking a back seat to so many "distractions"! But I'm still planning and gathering facts for when I actually bite the bullet.

I had an estimate from Kraftmaid today. I've also priced Barker Cabinets. They price out to close the same.

With Barker I really like the idea of frameless cabinets, solid wood, etc.

But with Kraftmaid I like the idea that they are assembled and the peace of mind that they were measured by the KD. (We did our own measuring with Barker and we're not changing the layout of present kitchen)

Since I've never actually seen Barker cabs I was wondering how they compare in quality. Any thoughts of what I should consider in picking between the two?

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

Be sure you are comparing like with like here. APC on the KM? And are the RTA cabinets actually finished, or do you have to finish them too? There are other brands out there besides KM. You shouldn't limit yourself to just them as a comparison.

Or, you can probably pay a contractor to assemble them for you. But at $50-$100 a box, there goes any savings that you might see, so you might as well be looking at additional pre assembled lines.

You need to narrow down the actual look that you want. If you want something common like shaker, then you can find that in every brand at every price point. What exactly are you looking for, and what's your budget? There's a whole world of cabinets out there, already assembled, if you don't want to do the assembly.

    Bookmark   March 3, 2013 at 10:10AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

Frameless was why I wanted Barker. I thought long and hard about Ikea but the ability to get custom sizes pushed us over to Barker. Also have you compared the quality of things like hinges and drawer glides to be sure your pricing is apples to apples?

The measuring by ourselves and getting the order right scared me as well. I won't know till they come if I got it right but what helped me was the following:.

1. Download and install the 30 day trial of Cabinet Vision that he talks about on his web site. You can then add his catalog of cabinets to the software to do your design. It wasn't too hard to learn and way less brain-dead than the Ikea planner and any of the other free ones I tried. This is real software, hence only the 30 day trial.

2. Draw it out in the software, then make a spreadsheet of all the cabinets, types, sizes, how many you need, etc.

3. Then get your spouse or another neutral party to go over the drawing and make sure it makes sense, that you have the right cabs in the right places.

4. Think and double check all the things you have learned here and from the Barker web site. Do you have at least 2" fillers on each wall? Do you have finished ends where you need them? Did you remember toe kick trim, molding etc. where you need them.

5. Check the spreadsheet against the drawing with another person, one looks at the software, one cross references the spreadsheet.

6. Take a break for a few days or a week.

7. Repeat steps 2-5 until you are comfortable.

8. Create an account on the barker website and put your items in the cart. It will save them, so don't order yet.

9. Print the contents of the cart.

  1. Double triple check the cart printout against your spreadsheet.

  2. Take a deep breath, put in your credit card number and submit the order.

  3. Tell yourself, well if one of them is wrong, we'll use it in the garage and order another one. Go have a drink and don't go over the order again :-)

Last word, don't rush it, take your time.

Hope that helps!

    Bookmark   March 3, 2013 at 10:15AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

Adding to lucas' list: measure and re-measure with someone else at the other end of the measuring tape. Every little bit counts and you don't want to find that you read the tape wrong.

    Bookmark   March 3, 2013 at 10:22PM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
Walnut slab for island with sink
We are building a home and I am considering using a...
KitchenAid Mixer - Sea glass or azure blue
I'm having a tough time deciding between the Sea glass...
how to deal with delays
our cabinets were supposedly on pace to be delivered...
lmgch (formerly on GW)
Do you like your Viscont White granite counters?
Like so many others, I lust over Calcutta gold marble...
Please help me with my layout options. Again.
Hello! Several months ago I posted to get layout advice...
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™