Need advice selecting a Water Softener, justalurker and others?

snowangJune 17, 2011

Hi All!

I'm a homeowner with no plumbing experience (or much plumbing knowlege at all!). We just moved in a new construction that has hard water from the private well. We already have a RO system in the kitchen for drinking and cooking (builder installed because of a high nitrogen level). Plan to have a water softener installed to remove the white scale I see all over the sinks, faucets and granite countertops (they are hard to get rid of!). I am also noticing sediment in the water coming out of the RO system. I find this a little perplexing since I thought RO was supposed to get rid of everything including any sediments. Anyway, we had Culligan out couple weeks ago and the guy did a water test and gave us a quote of $2245 for a HE 10" Water Softener. Thinking that's a little higher than what I would be willing to pay, I researched on buying my own equipment and having a local plumber install it. I've heard some postive things on this forum about OhioPureWater so I started with filling out their evaluation form online and getting a quote. Below is the information I filled in the form:

> People in Home: 5

> Number of Full Bathrooms: 3 (one jacuzzi)

> Hardness Value: 25

> Hardness Unit: gpg

> Iron Value: 0

> Iron Unit: ppm

> pH Value: 7.5

> Flow Rate: 8 (not sure about this)

> Raw Water Color: yes

> Raw Water Odor: no

> Raw Water Clear: no

> Raw Water Is Clear but turns color overnight: no

> Sediment present overnight: yes

> Slimy buildup in tank: yes

> Iron stains on fixtures: no

> Water Line Size: 1"

> Pump Type: Submersible

And their sales emailed me back with these recommendations:


Based on the information in your evaluation, here are the items I would recommend for your application......

1.) Our 1.5 cu/ft ChemSorb sediment removal filter, with the Automatic Backwashing, Fleck 2510 - 12 Day Timer valve....that will help remove color in your water caused by sediment.

The unit would be set to automatically backwash every 6 days with 5 people in the home, and should be installed in the main water line after the well pressure tank, before the softener unit, and can be located at this link on our website...

1ea Fleck 2510 Auto Backwash ChemSorb Sediment Filter 1.5

10x54 resin tank

1.5 cubic feet of mixture

10 gpm service flow rate

7 gpm backwash flow rate

Selected options:

Fleck Valve Connection: 1 Inch Stainless Bypass Valve

Tank Color Option: Blue

2.) Our 48,000 grain water softener with the Fleck 2510SXT Metered valve, for whole house filtration of hardness from your water, and can be located at this link on our web site.....

I would recommend this softener be installed after the well pressure tank, and be set to regenerate every 1300 gallons, which would be an average regeneration of about every 4 - 5 days, with 5 people in the home....

1ea Fleck 2510SXT - Metered On Demand Control Valve Water Softener 48000 Grain Capacity

10x54 resin tank

1.5 cubic feet of resin

12 gpm service flow rate

2.5 gpm backwash flow rate

Floor Space Required is 26x15x62

Selected options:

Fleck Valve Connection: 1 Inch Stainless Bypass Valve

Tank Color Option: Blue

Brine Tank Size: 15x17x36 Rect Brine Tank

Softening Resin (1.5 cuft): High Capacity Resin


My question is: Are the products he recommended the right ones for us? Regarding the sediment filter, I told him we already have a small one (with the yellowish stuff inside) installed by the builder and he said theirs self-wash and will never need a replacement cartridge. It'll cost me an additional $600 installed. Is it worth it and will it get rid of the sediment I'm getting even from the RO system?

I've read from Justalurkers posts that a Noryl bypass is preferred but it seems like there is no 1" Noryl bypass option. They only have 1" Noryl yoke. So I guess I'll have to use the stainless steel 1" they recommended. I've also learned that I should ask for a top basket from the seller and ask my plumber to put in a 3 ball valve bypass using 1/4 turn ball valves (even though I have no idea what that is).

Anything I'm missing here?

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

Based on the info you provided IMO a 1.5 cube softener is too small. A 1.5 cube softener would be operating at the least efficient salt dose and costing you a lot of money.

No RO should be operating of water that has a hardness of 25 gpg. More than likely you've already hosed the RO membrane. Since the builder installed that and the sediment filter don't listen to anything he says regarding water treatment as he has proved he knows nothing about the subject.

    Bookmark   June 17, 2011 at 1:12PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

"....sediment I'm getting even from the RO system? "

I'm reading this to mean you're saying you see sediment coming out of your RO drinking water spigot. If that's the case, either your membrane's trashed or your post-filter or something downstream of it is disintegrating or both. You do have filters in there, right? Needs inspection and correction. Also recommend getting yourself a TDS meter so you can measure quality of RO output.

Your RO stands alone. Even if sediment comes to it, it will not flow out of it. Something's wrong right there. Don't mix that up with some idea of a sediment filter upstream solving the problem. The problem is within the RO system itself.

    Bookmark   June 17, 2011 at 4:00PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

Hi Justalurker, I will get a 2.0 cubic feet then. Just curious, is your recommendation for a larger resin based on the hardness level or number of people in the house and usage? How should we set the regeneration frequency for it to be most efficient?

What's the reasonable cost for installing just the softener in an unfinished basement in the Greater Washington DC area? The OhioPureWater guy told me roughly $200-250. But the quotes I've been getting has been much higher (I've called a lot of plumbers). The lowest I can get is around $300-$450, and they won't give me a fixed price.

And to Asolo, too, I first saw the sediment in the RO water when I moved in two months ago. Just observed the water again yesterday and no sediment was found either from RO or the untreated water. Not sure what changed but I guess I won't need an expensive sediment filter as the sales guy recommended. Thanks!

    Bookmark   June 20, 2011 at 12:49PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

Water softeners are sized based on the water conditions, # of people, # of bathrooms, and other variables.

Based on what you posted you should be looking at around a 3.5 cu ft softener and with it setup to operate at an efficient salt dose will regenerate every 7 days.

You might get by with a 2.5 cu ft softener but it will not operate as efficiently (will use more salt) and have a lower SFR.

As for installation... if the water service is accessible in the basement and there is a drain and an electrical outlet you're basically looking at local plumber rates and materials. Plumbers can install softeners, and some install them backwards, so an install by a water treatment pro is preferred.

Before you make any decisions may I suggest...

Hit the Yellow Pages and call at least three local water treatment pros. Make sure you call at least one of the big dogs like Kinetico or Culligan for comparison and at least a couple independent pros.

Give each an opportunity to offer suggestions and provide you with a quote to meet your water treatment needs. IGNORE ANY THAT DON'T TEST YOUR WATER THEMSELVES as they can't speak intelligently to water treatment without knowing what needs to be treated.

Ask lots of questions. Softening the entire house or just the water heater (IMO a bad idea)? Warranty, parts & labor or just parts, how long and on exactly what? Install, permits required, licensed plumber? Routine maintenance and costs? Do they stock parts? Response time for emergency (water leak) calls? If they don't explain things to your satisfaction that is a good indicator of how you'll be treated after the sale.

Are all your treatment needs being addressed?

Ask your neighbors if they have any water treatment experience. They might tell you who's good or who to avoid.

Come back here and post the specific recommendations and hardware components with the costs and we'll give you our opinions.

    Bookmark   June 20, 2011 at 1:58PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

About the should NEVER have seen sediment from the RO at ANY time or under ANY circumstance. It is a completely stand-alone separate system with components specifically designed NOT to pass sediment (or much of anything else). Since you've seen that it has, I would advise your checking it out or having it checked out.

    Bookmark   June 20, 2011 at 2:20PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

BTW, what diameter is the pipe in your home... 3/4" or 1"?

    Bookmark   June 20, 2011 at 3:17PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

The pipe is 1". I did consult with many local well and pump professionals as well as plumbing companies. It seems to me that purchasing my own equipment and having a plumber install in my unfinished basement would be the most cost effective, with between 1/3 to half cost savings. I just want to make sure that the equipment sold by OhioPureWater is a good price for the quality.
Is it true that for the same amount of water regenerated, the higher the grain capacity of the softener, the more efficient (less salt needed) it is? So in essence, even if I am paying $100 more for each additional 0.5 cubic feet of the equipment, my annual savings on the salt consumption may be even more than $100?
Sorry about these entry-level questions :P

    Bookmark   June 22, 2011 at 3:03PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

You have 1" plumbing and the recommended control valve is 3/4"? I'd be looking at 1" valves, but that's just me.

The aim is to size the softener to regenerate every 7 days or so with an efficient salt dose while providing adequate SFR (service flow rate) to accommodate the number of people, bathrooms, appliances, and fixtures... like a Jacuzzi. It can be a difficult balance to achieve and that's why so many softener sellers don't bother and the customers ends up with an appealing price and an under sized softener and spends far more money on salt than they should.

If you under size then hardness leaks through at peak flow... if you're paying for soft water you ought to get it.

If you're looking for the cheapest solution bear in mind that buying online you get no service by definition... regardless of the seller and OPWC is a reputable seller. You will have a plumber hook up the softener (right or wrong) and then you get to learn how to program it and I guarantee you that OPWC will not give you efficient settings so where will you get them?.

It will cost you nothing to investigate local independent water treatment professionals and you can learn a lot. You might find that local pros are price competitive and install, program, and service what they sell.

    Bookmark   June 22, 2011 at 4:47PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

Thanks, Justalurker. I researched online and found many calculators for the right effiency level and you are absolutely right that I need something like 2.5 or even 3 cubic feet. I'll bear that in mind when I order.
Looks like the 1" valves are much more expensive and doesn't include bypass configurations as part of the package, at least on OPWC. This is from their website: Fleck 9000 1" Meter On Demand Control valve (Note: the Fleck 9000 1" valve is directly connected to. If you need to bypass the water softener, you must construct your own plumbing bypass configuration). They also don't come with electronic meters (which I assume would be easier to comprehend for homeowners, but I may be wrong and they can be harder to fix in case broken). But I will again, bear your advice in mind.

Culligan recommended a 10" softener and the cost is $2,250. And another local well and pump company quoted $1,950 for Master MP-CLR-45UF. That's 45k grains so smaller than what I actually need. By the way, their specifications referred to a 1" Service Pipe and 3/4" Drain Pipe. Is this the best configuration for my situation? I have seen only 1" pipes in my near the pressure tank in my basement. The plumbing company that is actually going to install my own softener equipment also quoted me for their equipment (a 60k grain two tank unit from CSI Model MS64) plus labor, at $1,500. I don't think their equipment has the Fleck valves though.

I understand I'll bear the risk of no service. But at $885 for a 80k grain equipment and $400 max for installation labor, that risk is probably worth it. I suspect if I were to get the same capacity with the local companies, the price is going to be prohibitive for our budget.

    Bookmark   June 24, 2011 at 11:59AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

I can't stress the importance enough of involving a water treatment professional even if just for consultation. Plumbers and well companies are not water treatment professionals and don't know what they don't know about water treatment.

As for service size, where are you seeing 1" pipe? Your service size is the pipe from the well to the storage tank.

Buying softeners online can be really confusing...

FYI, The Fleck 7000 is an 1.25" valve and comes with a bypass and is less money than a 3/4" Fleck 2510SXT... see how easy it is when you know what you're looking for?

Guessing what the local companies will charge is not the same as knowing what the local companies will charge.

So go out there and price a 3 or 3.5 cu ft softener with a Fleck 7000SXT with top basket and bypass, Fleck 2310 safety float, and standard resin. Make sure you're getting the top tier quality components and not second best. When you find what you think you want buy it and have the local plumber install it. If all goes well up to that point then program it correctly and for efficient operation.

The best deal around is a dollar's worth for a dollar. Many people want to pay 75 cents and get a dollar's worth but almost always they end up spending 75 cents and getting 50 cents worth. Water treatment equipment is an area where many spend more than they have to to get what they don't need. Lots of people buy softeners that end up as door stops.

Keep us informed what you decide so your experience can help others.

    Bookmark   June 24, 2011 at 12:25PM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
Fed up and ready to tackle my well water issues
I've been reading posts trying to educate myself for...
Help with smelly well water
Just a little background. We bought a house 3 years...
Supply lines above subfloor, what are my options?
I am installing new floating vanities in my 2nd story...
Hot water backflowing into cold supply
OK, I'm rephrasing my question, as what I'd asked before...
Terminox ISM for iron/manganese removal
Hi, I have had a water softener with other assorted...
Sponsored Products
British Colonial Swivel Barstool Cover - Sand
$179.50 | FRONTGATE
Franklin Sofa - Key Largo Grape Purple
Joybird Furniture
Serena & Lily Diamond Pillow Cover
Serena & Lily
Bentley Glider and Ottoman - White - 70947-266
$299.99 | Hayneedle
Horizontal Weave 4-Light Antique Brass Multi Light Pendant
Lamps Plus
Nostalgic Two-Light Lantern
$295.95 | Bellacor
Blue & White Large Sink Mat
$22.99 | zulily
Zuo Modern Wire/Mesh Espresso Seat Cushion
Euro Style Lighting
People viewed this after searching for:
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™