gas or electric

green_mamaNovember 13, 2011

I am in need of some direction on heating in my home!!

I have been having some issues with people giving me estimates on things and want some outside help to decide what to do!! I just bought an older house in PA, about 2100 sqft. Not all that well insulated which I am working on improving; duct work isn't well or at all insulated and the duct work in the crawl space (6" flexpipe ) seems to be crushed in some places.

I currently have a 11 year old Williamson oil furnace with a 1000 gal in-ground tank (not sure how old it is). I have been told by one company that the heat exchanger is cracked, but others have come and said it is fine.

I was thinking of replacing it (cost of oil being what it is) with either a gas furnace or an all electric unit with a heat pump. I live in a very rocky area, so I am assuming it would cost a lot to dig a trench for the gas line the 125 ft to the house. Getting an excavator to give me an estimate has been a joke. They have all said that they would let me know how much it would be once they dig it, find out what they run into and see how much time it takes. Un yeah, I'll just go in blindly - I have lots of money to throw around! I have gotten estimates for a :

Trane 2.5 ton, 30,000 BTUH all-electric heat pump system with the Trane variable-speed indoor air handler with 68,000 BTUH back-up electric heaters- $8,660.00

Carrier 2.5 ton 15 seer heat pump and Performance variable speed fan/coil unit - $9,935

Trane 4 ton xl 15i heat pump with hyperion xl variable speed air handler, media air cleaner, touch screen thermostat - $16,312 This company figured in replacing duct work in crawlspace to 7", increasing the amount of heat vents and cold air returns in the house, insulating the duct work. They were in the house for 4 hours whereas everyone else was there for 20-30 minutes and seemed to just go with the size of the old units. And it seems to me that if the duct work and vents arent adequate, then the furnace isnt really working efficiently anyway.

I think my questions are: should I go with getting a gas line installed for a gas furnace and heat pump?

Get an electric furnace and spend the extra money fixing the insulation and duct work?

who is right on the ton size furnace I need for 2100 sqft?

should I just stick with the oil furnace I have and add on a heat pump?

AHH! This is so confusing - if anyone can help I'd greatly appreciate it!!

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

Have you talked to the gas company? They might be a good resource for the cost to hook up. They might cover some or all the costs since they profit by you going that way. In lots of areas, the gas company will go 125 ft to your house for free.

PA is a big state. How long you are planning to be in the house makes a big difference. Gas is probably the best long term choice but the colder you are, the more of a difference it makes. So if you are in the mountains away from the coast and you are planning on living there 20 years, then the gas line is worth a lot more than if you are in a warmer area and plan on moving in 5 years.

Have you looked at geothermal? What are your electric rates and NG rates?

No easy answer except that if you go all electric, consider a very good heat pump - not the cheapest.

    Bookmark   November 14, 2011 at 5:25AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

I certainly would not go with a 2 1/2 ton system..

You need a load calculation first and foremost.

Taking into consideration your location and winter climate, I would not go with a HP that did not have electronic demand defrost whether electric backup or nat gas backup.

Just from your description it sounds like ductwork should be replaced with all new or major repairs at the very least.

Call your nat gas distributor for recommendations on pricing to get nat gas line inside your home.

Depending on rates, you might be better off going all nat gas heat rather than dual fuel system.

I would get rid of the oil.


    Bookmark   November 14, 2011 at 8:58AM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
HVAC billing question
Question for the pros...... So I had a faulty capacitor...
Moving floor vent to toekick area
Hello. We are renovating our kitchen as well as baths...
Seeking input on HVAC replacement
I am getting ready to do a full replacement. Current...
What's your average gas heating bill in Winter?
I just bought a house in Richmond, VA. Just called...
Honeywell th6320R Thermostat
My Honeywell TH6320R thermostat (communicating with...
Sponsored Products
Hampton Bay Lightbulbs 12-Volt Low Voltage 7-Watt Incandescent Wedge Bulbs
$3.99 | Home Depot
Clouds Clips 12-Inch Two-Light Fluorescent Brushed Nickel Square 2000 Lumen LED
$500.00 | Bellacor
Trademark Chandelier by Currey & Company
$810.00 | Lumens
Grass Gator String Trimmer Replacement Cutting Head - 1223-0975
$26.99 | Hayneedle
Variable Light Vanity Mirror
$159.00 | FRONTGATE
Frozen Snow & Ice Light Vine
$15.99 | zulily
Juno Trac-Lites 50 Watt PAR20 Flared Chrome Track Head
$25.99 | Lamps Plus
Juno Track Lighting Trac-Lites Bronze Conduit Connector R34BZ
$13.97 | Home Depot
People viewed this after searching for:
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™