American Standard vs. Carrier

robert6011November 16, 2011

I am currently evaluating two proposals for a new HVAC system in my home.

OPTION 1 is American Standard.

OPTION 2 is Carrier.

I would appreciate any advice!

Thank you!

OPTION 1

1st Fl. - will remove existing equipment only, recover freon for EPA reclamation; install Carrier Infinity 18 SEER 2 stage condenser, Carrier Performance variable speed fancoil, 3.5 ton net btu cool.

2nd Fl. - will remove existing system complete (except grills), otherwise same as above but a Carrier Infinity 18 SEER 2 stage condenser 4 ton system; Carrier Performance variable speed fancoil, all new zoning equipment, dampers, 2 stage t-stats,

This proposal includes removing all existing equipment, installing new equipment, transitioning to Puron or enviorn safe freon operating systems; removing 2nd floor ductwork also, 1st floor duct remains. Leak check on existing line sets will be extra; we can determine if better solution is to install new copper line sets at installation, same will be extra. If more supply air vents, return air ducts, or any duct fabrication is needed, same will be extra. If the 1st floor system requires new zone control panel and dampers, same will be extra.

� Total Estimate = $30,650

OPTION 2

AMERICAN STANDARD 17 SEER TWO STAGE A/C W/ HYDRO HEATING

FIRST FLOOR:

-Supply and install (1) 4 Ton 410A Variable Speed Air Handler

-Supply and install (1) H2O Hydro coil with temp. Control aqua-stat

-New Air Handler will be installed in basement on vibration isolators

-Supply and install (1) 4 Ton 410A Condensing Unit

-New condenser will be located outside on A/C pad

-Supply and Install all necessary refrigerant piping to be run to Air Handler

-Supply and Install E-Z Trap condensate drain line that will run outside of house

-We will fabricate and install supply and return air trunk ducts of galvanized sheet metal of

proper gauge and size

-Supply and install (1) Two stage zone Control Panel (two zones)

-Supply and install (2) automatic zone dampers

-Supply and install Bypass damper and ductwork

-We will install freeze-stat to prevent evaporator coil from freezing

-We will make all necessary control wiring connections

-Supply and install necessary air diffusers and return grills

-Supply and install (2) Touch screen, two stage digital programmable thermostats

-We will make all necessary control wiring connections

-New ductwork will be insulated with R-8 insolation

-Supply and install take offs with balancing dampers

-Start up and check test of operation

-10 year manufacturers warranty on all functional parts

-10 year manufacturers warranty on compressor

-2 year labor warranty on all installed equipment

*We will install new ductwork by air handle location.

*First floor ductwork will be inspected for proper size

*Main ductwork to kitchen not able to see above ceiling if there�s room to fit larger size duct

SECOND FLOOR:

-Supply and install (1) 3 Ton 410A Variable Speed Air Handler

-Supply and install (1) H2O Hydro coil with temp. Control aqua-stat

-New Air Handler will be installed in attic on vibration isolators

-Supply and install (1) 3 Ton 410A Condensing Unit

-New condenser will be located outside on A/C pad

-Supply and Install all necessary refrigerant piping to be run to Air Handler

-Supply and Install E-Z Trap condensate drain line that will run outside of house

-We will install secondary drain pan with safety switch

-We will fabricate and install supply and return air trunk ducts of galvanized sheet metal of

proper gauge and size

-Supply and install (1) Two stage zone Control Panel (two zones)

-Supply and install (2) automatic zone dampers

-Supply and install Bypass damper and ductwork

-We will install freeze-stat to prevent evaporator coil from freezing

-We will make all necessary control wiring connections

-Supply and install necessary air diffusers

-Supply and install (2) Touch screen, two stage digital programmable thermostats

-We will make all necessary control wiring connections

-We will relocate (1) central return in hallway

-We will install branch take offs of round pipe and flexible ducts

-New ductwork will be insulated with R-8 isolation

-Supply and install take offs with balancing dampers

-Start up and check test of operation

-10 year manufacturers warranty on all functional parts

-10 year manufacturers warranty on compressor

-2 year labor warranty on all installed equipment

-All equipment refrigerant piping will be flushed with RX-11 Solution

Included: We will have license electrician connect existing electrical to new equipment

Not included:

-New electric, control wiring or electrical conduits

-Relocation of any existing obstructions and Permits

-Patching and painting walls or ceilings to access existing ductwork or equipment.

-Main ductwork to kitchen area

Total investment cost for the above proposed work will be��. $26,000.00

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
heatseeker

american standard

    Bookmark   November 17, 2011 at 8:31AM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
Thoughts on proposed HVAC system?
To start: my house is two-level (main plus upper)...
gbleeker
Opinions please Mitsubishi M - S E R I E S H I G H P E R F O R M A N C
Our HVAC guy is suggesting this for a complete system...
almostemptynester
Geothermal in new construction.
Our house is currently under construction, and while...
bethmcg
No Fully Trained Mini Split Installers
Reading threads about mini split heat pumps I got curious...
nerdyshopper
Is this HVAC system OK?
Replacing original old ~9 seer unit. House is 2001...
thereloader
Sponsored Products
Piper Black Tech Lighting Mini Pendant
Euro Style Lighting
Beachcomber Ceiling Fan by Hunter Fans
$189.00 | Lumens
Swag Style Cream Roses Giclee Shade Plug-In Chandelier
Lamps Plus
Evergreen Medium Clear Seedy Sycamore Outdoor Wall Mount
$456.00 | Bellacor
Bruck | Sierra Sconce
$315.75 | YLighting
Select Luxury E.C.O. Standard-size Latex Pillow
Overstock.com
People viewed this after searching for:
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™