Replacing HVAC for leaking evap coil

john815May 9, 2010

My home in Phoenix presently has a Tempstar (ICP) 9600 A/C with gas furnace, installed 1995. Evap coil has developed leaks every 1 to 3 years requiring multiple replacements, fortunately covered by extended warranties. Service people have always seemed puzzled by the repeated leaks but from reviewing forums it looks like this is a recognized problem.

Looking at Lennox or Trane for full replacement - are these the best, is one rec. over the other?

One estimate is for Lennox XC21-048-230 condenser with an ADP LC42/60Y9CG coil, the guy said that Lennox uses ADP coils; with Lennox G60UHV-60C-090 furnace.

Second estimate is for same Lennox condenser, and furnace, but with Lennox CH33-50/60C-2F coil - for a lower overall price.

Other option would be Trane such as XL20i.

Does this Trane have aluminum coil, which it looks like doesn't have the rust/leak problem?

If I go with variable speed furnace/air handler and leave fan on full time will this prevent condensation and rust on the coil and reduce chance of leaking?

Is the proposal to use an ADP coil a scam or legit?


Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

Trane and Lennox are good brands, but not the only ones worth considering. A lot of equipment is similar nowadays with respect to available features, performance, reliability, etc. You have to be comparing apples to apples, however.

The Trane 20i is a nice system with two compressors for better staging between high and low (around 50% capacity on low vs. 75% for the Lennox).

Lennox doesn't "use" ADP coils. The dealer is pairing it with an ADP coil likely to boost the efficiency of the overall systme (if trying to get tax credit qualifications). Probably just a misconception there.

Trane uses aluminum for most of their coils (though not in air handlers with the current production, but this is supposed to be changing soon). Post a model number. The Trane dealer may be using an Aspen third-party coil like the Lennox dealer. I would stick to Trane and Lennox OEM coils if possible. Many Trane coils are aluminum (4TXC model is, but not sure about all others), but that doesn't mean they won't or can't leak. I do think the aluminum is more reliable in terms of leaking than copper (due to corrosion), but both can leak, and most brands provide a 10 year warranty now to protect you somewhat.

    Bookmark   May 9, 2010 at 9:33PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

I'm replacing my ADP coil after two years of operation. I have a small leak in one of the capillary tubes. When I spoke with a Trane authorized dealer I was informed of two things. First the ADP coil does not carry the same warranty as Trane 1-5yrs in my case vs. 5-10 for trane. Second, even though ADP is going to replace the coil they will not warranty it beyond the date of the original start-up. ADP's clock starts running 1yr after manufacturing. They don't keep records of when they were sold or who they sold them to. This is probably not the case it's their customer service center passing this along. So as I would see it if your Heat and AC guy is pairing an ADP coil with your AC it's about cost. Here in Ga many companies working for builders rig these combos to save the builder money and to keep a job with them. Save yourself the headache and go with all trane parts because you aren't going to get the warranty with ADP. Most importantly our service men are receiving calls on these all the time.
ADP builds them to order now so they don't have as much standing inventory as they once did, but consider this. They build a coil in the hay-day of building and it sits on a shelf for 6 mos. The builder has a system installed around that same time but doesn't sell the house and 18 mos later the bank owns it. Someone comes along buys the house from the bank and has the system turned on and the coil is already out its 1yr warranty. The Trane furnace is still in warranty but the coil is not. Just a thought.

    Bookmark   June 10, 2011 at 8:52AM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
Blown in insulation vs spray foam
I am looking for advice. I have a home built in 2000...
Who do I call about a whole-house fan?
I'd like a whole house fan. This might be a DIY project,...
No Fully Trained Mini Split Installers
Reading threads about mini split heat pumps I got curious...
Central Air OR Mini-Split
Hello everyone, We bought our house 2 years ago (1938...
Does Air Duct Cleaning really help?
We live in a 40 year old home with a forced air gas...
Sponsored Products
Blue Glass Drawer Pull
Signature Hardware
Crackle Glass 20 Inch Outdoor Wall Lantern -Black Copper
$74.10 | Bellacor
Outdoor Parkdale Rug in Sunbrella Criss Cross Pink/Melon White Wicker - 5' x 8'
$599.00 | FRONTGATE
Moonrays Outdoor Lighting. Outdoor Black Solar Powered Color-Changing LED Love S
$19.98 | Home Depot
BAP Wall Task Lamp by Luceplan
$330.74 | Lumens
Tech Lighting | Ecran Low Voltage Pendant Light
$329.60 | YLighting
Heath Zenith Security Sensors 240 Degree Bronze Replacement Motion Sensor
$49.98 | Home Depot
Stone Mill Hawthorne Oil-rubbed Bronze Cabinet Pulls (Pack of 25)
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™