I have received 3 requests for Harry Potter scarves! My nephews are ages 6, 8 & 9. First of all I would make them smaller than the 55" long. My question is, on the "atypically" site, she made the scarves in the round. I would like to have both sides look the same, so I guess that's the only way to get it, right? What do you all think of doing the scarves in the round? Have you ever done it? Are they too thick or heavy?