Regular poly carpet or SmartStrand?

IndeciderOctober 17, 2013

If you had to choose between these for your "forever" dream home (that also contains two small children and one dog), which would you go with?

#1 - A 60 oz multi-colored frieze from the backroom stock of a local store. Salesmen doesn't provide itemized quote, but price for carpet, 8lb pad and install is $5500. Based on the price (for 150 sq yds), I doubt this is a SmartStrand fiber. They are very secretive with the carpet's "stats" other than to tout the 60 oz faceweight and how nice it feels. I assume the carpet is about $24/yd which I feel is pricey for regular polyester.

#2 - A 35 oz multi-colored frieze, which I can order in any color available, from big box store. Verified installer is local, trusted company and got detailed install quote to avoid surprise charges. $4500 for everything.

My thoughts:
The product from the local store is likely better, but I'm worried the poly fibers are going to mat down super quickly since it's not SmartStrand. Meanwhile, DH loves the pricetag on the 35 oz big box carpet and his logic is that our kids and dog will thrash whatever we get, so let's go cheap and replace later.

I then counter with the fact that the $5500 for the better carpet will be part of our mortgage, so what's $1000 if it makes the carpet last twice as long? Installing new in a brand new house with no furniture is easy. Getting new carpet in a house you live in is a PITA. And then it's out of pocket and not part of the mortgage.

Honestly, I'd spend $10k if someone could truly promise the carpet would last 15 years and look great. But I know that hardly anyone actually honors those wear warranties so I will not purchase based on some "warranty".

I believe both products will have the same stain resistance due to the poly content. What I don't know is which will wear better...normal poly with higher weight or SmartStrand with lower weight? I will be "crushed" (haha) if what I choose ends up matted down within the year. Any help is appreciated. Sorry for lenght, wanted to include details.

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

I just posted a thread in Remodeling asking if I would regret getting the regular poly carpet. I know the answer already though. Sigh. We don't have high traffic, but still.....

I think, based on past threads, you're going to be told to get the best now, and go with the SmartStrand. I have a feeling we are going to be replacing this carpet sooner than later!
With two kids and a dog yes that is going to "try" the carpet. But, it's still thousands of dollars, and are you going to want to replace all that in just a few years?
In our case, it's only two bedrooms. One of which I'm hoping stays as a guest BR where we never get guests. I'm hoping that DD stays in her own place - crossing fingers. She was SO hard on the carpet in her room it was unbelieveable. So we waited and waited till she moved.

    Bookmark   October 19, 2013 at 11:31AM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
Any experience with BellaCera hardwood flooring and/or hickory wood?
We fell in love with a hickory hardwood in their line,...
Carpet on concrete..what is proper installation?
Want to install carpeting on cement slab foundation,...
3/8 vs 1/2 inch thick engineered hardwood for staple down installation
We are trying to decide between two similar engineered...
What to use on edging and stairs when stripping of old hardwood floor
We are in the process of stripping and refinishing...
No hardwood warranty from HOM Furniture store - midwest
So after falling in love with Birch engineered floor...
Sponsored Products
NBA Los Angeles Lakers Rectangular: 5 ft. x 8 ft. Tailgater Mat
$159.95 | Bellacor
Safavieh Indoor/Outdoor Area Rug: Safavieh Rugs Shag Grey/Blue 5 ft. 3 in. x 7
Home Depot
Red Carpet Studios Cosmix 14 in. Double Spinner - Chrome - 31074
$34.99 | Hayneedle
United State Air force Academy Basketball Round: 2 Ft. 2 In. x 2 Ft. 2 In. Rug
$26.95 | Bellacor
nuLOOM Moroccan Trellis Shag Ivory Rug (6'7 x 9')
Maggie Area Rug
$89.99 | zulily
Couristan 0088-4091 Tides Creme Indoor/Outdoor Rug Multicolor - 00884091020037T
$24.00 | Hayneedle
Lilybeth Rug 8' x 10' - ivory/BLU/GOLD
$1,899.00 | Horchow
People viewed this after searching for:
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™