Pottery Barn Sofa vs Lee

daphne94September 11, 2010

After 10 years of owning a oversized Thomasville leather sofa I decided I would like to purchase either 2 new oversized sofas or a small sectional with a chaise and 1 sofa. I recently moved and the old sofa doesn't fit the space and endured 3 children being potty trained, a dog(no longer with us),and years of wear and tear.

I narrowed my search down to 2 brands Lee and Pottery Barn.

I like both because they have slip cover sofas that are machine washable, both have deep seating, and the look I am interested in.

The pros of the Pottery Barn are the microsuede, which is allegedly indestructible, replaceable covers if need be, the configurations and sizes I need.

If I go with the 2 sofas from PB I will go with the Basic Grand brand because I prefer the 3 cushion couch. If I decide on the sectional I will go with the

Comfort Brand because that sectional is available in the deep seating (Chaise and sofa component) and a matching Comfort Grand sofa.

PB Cons I am worried about quality, and itÂs a little pricey.

Lee has a sofa model # 3917, I would purchase 2, which is comparable to the PB Basic Grand, slightly less expensive but with Sunbrella velvet fabric. Cons are that it is not as stain resistant as the PB slip cover and not quite as deep.

If I go with the sectional I like Lee model #7117 (chaise and sofa component) and then separate piece 1 couch from the same series. All same size as the PB Grand but with Sunbrella fabric.

So it's Lee vs. PB. Has anyone had experience with either? Does the PB microsuede really hold up well? Any experience with either's sofa quality?

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

imho, i hate microsuede. it's unmistakably fake looking ...and looks cheap. i'm sorry, but i had to be honest. especially since you are comparing PB to a reputable company like lee. i have been dealing with them a lot lately as i purchased two sofas from them (linen slipcovers w/down-feather cushions) as well as a velvet bed for my daughter. both orders were customized: the sofas i chose came with two seat cushions. i prefer one, so they gave me one at no additional charge. the bed is a little different in that i wanted the same height headboard and footboard so it would resemble a day bed. there was a slight up charge but if i remember correctly it was only $100.
you should consult with your dealer on any design changes you'd like, or perhaps they could recommend a different model that would satisfy. also: quality aside, i tend to steer clear of the retail chains as they are without fail more expensive. crate & barrel sells lee, but you'll pay a higher markup.
as for the durability of microsuede, i can't answer. i'd never drink wine out of a plastic cup either.

    Bookmark   September 12, 2010 at 12:52AM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
Ethan Allen furniture... comments on quality
We're looking at Ethan Allen furniture. I know it was...
crate barrel sofa quality
what can be said about the crate and barrel sofa quality...
Hancock & Moore older leather chair, maybe H&M sofa,can they be saved?
I have an opportunity to pick up this chair and sofa...
Couch for Big and Tall Guy
What suggestions would you all offer on what to look...
Duane Collie - Question, Please!
Our H & M Kodiak sofa, love seat, chair & ottoman...
People viewed this after searching for:
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™