Need Advice on Garage Door Choices

Crystal6145July 3, 2013

I have settled on an 7 x 16 Amarr garage door. The models I am deciding from are the Heritage 3000 and the Olympus 500.

The Heritage is cheaper by $450, made from 24 gauge steel, 2" thick, but is insulated with polystyrene with an r value of 9.

The Olympus is only 27 gauge steel, also 2" thick, but is insulated with the better polyurethane blowin in with an r value of 19 and has 1 year longer hardware warranty.

My question is "will the polyurethane blown in insulation compensate in strength against dents for the 27 gauge vs. the stronger 24 gauge with the glued in polystyrene?"

I live in a very hot climate where 100 degree days are normal for several months of the year with mild winters, but do not heat/cool my garage and no living quarters above it so r value is important. I read that rvalue 16 is not double of rvalue 8 and is only about an energy savings of 5% so if this is right my main concern is strength and stability.

Thanks for any knowledge you may have.

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

If you don't heat or cool the space, what energy are you 'saving'?
I don't see r value being important here. More insulation slows the migration of heat into or out of a space, but the difference in this situation will not be noticable.

    Bookmark   August 16, 2013 at 9:38AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
Windows on Washington Ltd

No need to go with the higher R-Value core if there is not living space above the garage or if you aren't worried about keeping the garage more temperate.

The standard foam will give you plenty of impact protection and if you hit it hard enough to dent it with EPS, it will dent with polyurethane foam as well.

    Bookmark   August 20, 2013 at 9:03AM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
Craftsman Garage Opener Clicks only and LED blinking 5 times
My 1/2 HP Model 139.53641SRT opener clicks to all my...
craftsman 1/2 hp battery key pad ok / remotes &...
Need error codes for Craftsman 41A4315-7D.
Need error codes for Craftsman 41A4315-7D Garage Door...
Sears GDO does not close
I've searched on the forum without any luck. My Sears...
garage door remote opens but wont shut door
I have a 10 year old Craftsman garage door opener model...
Sponsored Products
Lithonia Lighting 4-Light Fluorescent White Strip Light Fixture TZR 2 54T5HO MVO
$69.97 | Home Depot
PlayStar Playsets Rigid Swing Seat - PS 7946
$33.99 | Hayneedle
PlayStar Playsets Commercial Grade Swing Hangers - PS 7576
$47.99 | Hayneedle
Genie PowerLift 900 1/2 HP Screw Drive Garage Door Opener - 37411V
$174.00 | Hayneedle
Lithonia Lighting Ceiling Mounted Lighting Wrap 4-Light Flush-Mounted White
$87.00 | Home Depot
Eti Ceiling Mounted Lighting 16 in. White LED Flush Mount Fixture Daylight
$69.99 | Home Depot
Westinghouse Outdoor Lanterns. 1-Light Weathered Bronze on Solid Brass Exterior
$72.60 | Home Depot
Homak 2 Door Wall Cabinet with Shelves - GS00727021
$108.99 | Hayneedle
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™