Epoxy Vs. Modular Garage Floor System? Help!

pokee99May 2, 2008

We just bought a brand new home and we have about 5 days at the end of May where the house is empty to do some work before we move in. One of the things we're thinking of doing is covering the garage floor with epoxy.

We have a painter we used before (and were happy with) and he is somewhat experienced with the prep and application of the epoxy product. It is very, very expensive (just over $2,000 for our 400 square foot garage) and is really going to pushing it for getting done in 5 days (it requires 3 days just to cure before you can walk on it, and with temps in May still being rather chilly where we live (in Vancouver).

I am trying to convince my husband to look into the Modular garage systems (the interlocking tiles). I like them because they are very durable, are easily installed and require no prep to the floor. I don't like them because water, dirt, oil, etc., gets trapped under the tiles and I could see that being a disgusting mess to clean up at some point (and if you don't clean it up, isn't that just utterly gross and almost toxic?).

I've heard that some professionals that apply epoxy can guarantee it for 20 years, but I wonder what that guarantee is. Hubby will be working on the cars in there (changing oil) and his motorcycle (doing everything), so there will be oil, gas, lubricants, chemicals of every kind going on that floor. I've heard stories that no paint can hold up to chemicals like that. Not to mention, we live in earthquake territory, so we get cracked pavement all the time. It's a new house, too, so it's going to settle and maybe there will be cracks. How is that going to affect the epoxy and the epoxy guarantee?

I'd be really curious to know if anyone has finished their garage floor and what they've used and how they've found it to be. We have about a week to decide and we're frantically trying to get as much info as we can.

Thanks in advance for your help!


Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

I cant speak to the modular floors. I have painted both my garage floors with epxoy that I got from Sherwin Williams (commercial grade). 1 is 5 years old and has shown some wear but it was an old floor before it was painted. The 2nd one I did last summer and it looks great but time will tell. I dont regret doing either one. So easy to clean up. The prep isnt that hard and it was a fun project. I have flecks in both floors and I recommend that for appearences.

    Bookmark   May 3, 2008 at 12:51PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

I just finished mine last week. I used interlocking tiles for the main floor, and epoxy for the upper landing area.

You might want to get a few more quotes, as $5/ft for the epoxy sounds on the high side. I've seen it advertised at Home Depot for about $2.50/ft.

You're correct that spills can get between the tiles. That's definitely a downside, but I view the tiles as essentially permanent. The next owner of my house can worry about it if they want to take the tiles out. You could also do a vapor barrier if you're really concerned - something simple like heavy plastic sheeting would do the trick.

Here's a couple photos.

    Bookmark   May 18, 2008 at 11:06PM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
Easy to use Backpack Blower Storage
I have been keeping my backpack blower on the floor...
Garage Door Exterior Lighting Help Please
Hello members, On the exterior, do you prefer lighting...
Moisture coming up through garage floor
House is in South Dakota. Split foyer. Built in 1977...
Snowblower help
I have a M t d model 317e760f118 track driven snow...
Unfinished Detached Carport from 1924
Hi, My house and an accompanying detached garage were...
People viewed this after searching for:
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™