Garage Door Torsion Spring: replace or not

sue2004March 16, 2007

Husband thinks we should replace the 2 spring on our single and double garage door. Both springs are just fine. The double door might need add a couple struts as it's making squaking noises now when opening. But both work just fine. THey are about 10 years old.

When I called a few service companies to get price quote, the CSR are a little bit surprised to hear that my springs are not broken and I want to replace it. So my first question is: should I really replce them?My neighbour's garage door once droped to the ground when the spring broke so I guess my hubby got the idea from the neighbour.

As I did some research/garage door 101, I found out that it's recommended for double door to use 2 torsion springs instead of 1. So the second question here is, if we do replace the, should we have that one bigger spring replaced with 2 springs for safety considerations?

Now my 3rd question: I got price quotes of one string on single door for $150, 2 springs on double door for $200, labor and parts included. Is the around the ballpark?

Any feedback is well appreciated!

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

If it were me and I had concerns I would invest in a service call by a technician and follow his recommendations. No one on this forum can possibly diagnose sight unseen. Most squeaks can be cured by lubricating.

    Bookmark   March 16, 2007 at 4:16PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

Those prices are dead on. My motto is if it aint broke, don't fix it. But, if you want to go ahead and do it is up to you guys.

A strut will not fix a squaking noise as you put it. If while the door is in the up position and it is sagging in the middle and as it go down you notice that section pop outward and the door jumps at the same time, then it needs a strut. Otherwise for the noise just use penetrating oil on all the rollers, hinges, bearing stands. You can use penetrating oil on the spring as well or grease. DO NOT PUT GREASE ANYWHERE ELSE BUT THE SPRING.

On the smaller door (if it has a torsion spring) one is fine. On the bigger door it is not uncommon to have one. Which is better? I personally like to have two b/c if one breaks the other one can help you lift your door to get the car out. Both systems work fine.

Usually if a spring breaks it will break in the down postition and not while the door is in motion, so I have no idea how your neighbors door could have just dropped. Especially if it is connected to on opener.

If you go with the two springs they may or may not try to charge you more for the conversion.

Hope this helps

    Bookmark   March 16, 2007 at 4:19PM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
Shop vacuum
Are there any good 12 -15 amp shop vacs that have 1200-1500...
Craftsman 3/4 HP Garage Door Opener w/Extension
I just installed a 9.18450 opener with a track extension...
Relocate Carriage House on new foundation?
Hi there. My 1985 Victorian home here in Maine also...
Craftsman Garage door openers old dipswitch technology
My garage door motors still work great- 30 years old....
Craftsman garage door opener problems
I am having trouble with my 3 year old Craftsman garage...
Sponsored Products
Old Town Wall Lantern
Martha Stewart Living™ Garage Wall Cabinet
Home Decorators Collection
Martha Stewart Living™ Garage Small Clear Bins - Set of 10
Home Decorators Collection
Wine Bottle Weathervane
$395.00 | FRONTGATE
NYC Metro Transit Sign Wall Plaque
Home Decorators Collection
Sportsman Series Gasoline 7000 Watt Generator
Beyond Stores
Downrods (one inch diameter) by Fanimation Fans
$20.00 | Lumens
LED Half Moon Deck Light by Kichler
$83.00 | Lumens
People viewed this after searching for:
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™