Help me decide between two hardwood flooring options

toothdoc78March 10, 2012

Hello, I'm new to this forum. :) My husband and I are trying to decide between two different hardwood flooring options for our house. The flooring will be covering our main floor foyer, hall, kitchen, and eating area, which is approximately 1000 sq feet. We currently have a light maple hardwood floor that is in not great shape and are looking to go with something a bit darker (not really dark though) and with a wider plank. The two options we're considering are both by Casabella flooring. One is Asian Walnut Antique Handscraped in Champagne.

http://www.casabellafloors.com/products.php?id=55#

The other is Maple Cottage Handsculpted in Amaretto.

http://www.casabellafloors.com/products.php?id=62

I'm interested in which would be more durable. We have two young kids and 3 cats, so scrapes and dents are a concern. This is one reason we were going with a wood with more character to it. Will the asian walnut change color like some of the other exotics? Is one better suited for our climate (I'm in Michigan)? The asian walnut has a 15 year finish warranty, while the maple has a 25 year finish warranty. Both have a combo polyurethane/aluminum oxide finish, although I think the maple is slightly glossier. I was leaning toward the walnut, but if the maple is going to have a better warranty, would I be better off going with that one?

Any input would be greatly appreciated. This will be professionally installed, and the price is just about the same for each.

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
Floortech

Two young children and cats will equal abrasions and dents and it will not take long. the warranties should not be a deciding factor in my opinion. If you are afraid of seeing wear then honestly hardwood will not be a great choice. In an active household, you will see the wear and disruption to the surface and it will be fast no matter what wood you choose. You must accept that thought process as many people get really surprised and think they bought bad wood. Hardwood shows wear and it shows it quickly.

    Bookmark   March 11, 2012 at 3:22AM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
Floor sanding/screening question
I just purchased my first home and decided to get the...
berlinswing
We might replace our wood floor with new....
I have 20yr old hardwood floor in our foyer. It is...
cindywhitall
carpet comparison
We are looking at 2 carpets right now. Both are Anso...
sutrotower96
bamboo floor fumes--anyone else have this problem??
Hi, has anyone installed a bamboo floor and had trouble...
nikwaters
Tiling on Cement Subfloor or Wood Subfloor?
I live in San Francisco and we are not near any water...
gqchynaboy
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™