spring/down or foam/down for seat cushion?

saydeApril 26, 2013

Looking at a Stickley chair (the Brookline) that offers spring down as standard. On some chairs it is an upgrade. I can see the difference in the cutaway model but can't seem to get a straight answer on what the differences are -- feel, durability -- and which is better. This is for a chair that will get a lot of use but we are small light people. I guess I am more interested in comfort than durability. In the store I sat in both (at least the sales person said they were one of each kind) and could not really tell the difference. Would appreciate any insight or experience with this . . . Thank you!

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

The biggest problem with a spring unit, or sometimes referred to as a marshall unit, is not so much the spring itself, but is the 1" or so thick foam that encases the spring unit. This 1" foam that covers the unit on top/bottom is what breaks down first, as its usually not of a high density type foam. This foam on both sides equal to 2" of seating support that once it breaks down and along with the normal softening of the polyester fiber or down/fiber blend wrap, makes the spring cushion a less durable cushion compared to a high density HR foam cushion.
If the spring unit is made from a larger stiffer wire, with either a very high density foam topper or a high density polyester pad then the spring unit will outlast a HR foam of same thickness.

    Bookmark   April 30, 2013 at 10:41PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

rmanbike, thank you for your very helpful and explicit response to my question. I appreciate it!

    Bookmark   May 13, 2013 at 10:31AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

One of the nice things about a spring cushion is the fast recovery of the cushion when you get up. The cushion tends to hold it's shape better than other cushions. Rmanbike is right make sure the foam that surrounds the coils in the cushion is a high quality foam. The coils within a spring cushion can also vary in their strength from soft to firm.

Another option is a spring down cushion which has several layers typically in this order, coils, fiber, foam, fiber and a down topper.

    Bookmark   May 26, 2013 at 9:47AM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
Slats or Boxspring?
Like the title says: Slats or Boxspring to support...
Couch for Big and Tall Guy
What suggestions would you all offer on what to look...
Ethan Allen furniture... comments on quality
We're looking at Ethan Allen furniture. I know it was...
Omnia leather furniture
We have seen a sofa by Omnia that we like - for around...
Bernhardt vs. Thomasville for leather.
Thinking of getting a leather sofa for its durability....
People viewed this after searching for:
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™