geo or solar for water heating?

razlNovember 5, 2007

I will be installing a geothermal unit in the northeast (RI). Would I be more economical to install a desuperheater add-on to the geothermal or go solar heating? I assume installing both would not make sense.

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

Good question.

We have a three ton geo heatpump (a Tranquility 27) with the desuperheater, but its inclusion was a mistake the installer made. We took it as was with the thought that it would be worthwhile enough after all, but I have not yet hooked it up. We only use the unit about half of the year (we need very little cooling) so I put it off over the summer ... well, you know the drill.

But I am attracted by the vacuum solar tubes, which are claimed to be useful here in western Montana even in overcast and cold conditions. We'd spend close to $3K on such a system, with an anticipated payoff (at current natural gas prices) of about 7 years.

But the desuperheater would cost me almost nothing more to finish installing, even though it added about $300 to my heatpump cost. I could probably recoup that in about three years. Right now it's just a sunk cost.

But "What if", since I already own the desuperheater, I installed it in tandem with the solar tubes? It would be at its most efficient at exactly the time the solar tubes were at their least efficient- when it was very cold. (Or I may be wrong- it may be that the tubes are plenty efficient when it's veryvery cold, as long as it's clear; it may be fog and overcast conditions that I need to worry about concerning the solar tubes.)

Well, I haven't answered your question, but there's my two-bits worth for now, and thanks for bringing the question up. Good luck to you and I hope we both learn something from this!


    Bookmark   November 5, 2007 at 5:38PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

ItÂs a no-brainer. If youÂre already installing geothermal, install the desuperheater too. If youÂre not satisfied with the result, then look to something else.



    Bookmark   November 6, 2007 at 9:44AM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
Best roof for solar panels
We recently bought a house. The roof is in bad condition...
Geothermal in south bay area
I am wondering if anybody has feedback on geothermal...
Solar Panel on Shed, Standalone?
I have a small shed, like 10' x 12'. It is about 30'...
I need a better way to finish this crown molding
Hi. Kitchen remodel, brand new cabinets with crown...
Geothermal $6K per ton?
In my ongoing quest into the geothermal world, this...
People viewed this after searching for:
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™