Pine doors with Oak Trim?

drugdocOctober 9, 2010

My wife and I are building a new home. We are having a bit of a dilemma selecting our doors and trim.

We will have pine windows and maple cabinets.

We are planning to use maple or hickory for the floors.

Our original quote was for 4-panel pre-finished pine doors from Western Building Products. Our trim is to be pre-finished oak stained to match the pine doors.

We like the look of the pine doors, but are concerned that the oak trim will look strange next the pine doors and windows due to the differences in wood grain.

The sales rep at the lumbar yard is telling me that people routinely use this combination and it is very popular. He said the stains will be customized at the factory and the colors should match very closely. When I asked about using pine for the trim - he said it would be similar in price, but he did not recommend it because it is a soft wood and is not as durable. He said a change to maple would be much more expensive.

Any thoughts or comments would be much appreciated.

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
brickton

Do you really expect your trim to take that much more abuse than the door? If pine is hard enough for the door... wouldn't it be hard enough for the trim?

I agree that pine floors aren't for everyone since they do get marked up, dinged and dented, but pine trim not being hard enough? That's new to me. And usually pine is a good deal cheaper than oak.

    Bookmark   October 11, 2010 at 8:44AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
allison0704

We have clear pine windows, doors and trim - all stained. We distressed them all by hand. It is a softer wood, but we've been in five years and the only problem is scratches at the lever (two exit doors) since the dog knows how to open them by himself.

Our floors are #2 oak. Veranda ceilings are spruce. Cabinets are a mixture.

fwiw, we didn't go with pine because it was less (I didn't compare to anything else). It gave us the look we wanted.

Here is a link that might be useful: my house tour

    Bookmark   October 12, 2010 at 10:15AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
hadley

I'd use pine. We, too, have clear pine trim in our old house (haven't built yet). It is more sensitive to a poorly aimed chair leg when moving furniture or a canister vac yanked crookedly through the doorway, but if you are even halfway careful with those sorts of things, you should avoid dings. If you do get a few and don't like the patina, softer wood is easier to sand and re-smoothe and re-stain. When staining soft wood like pine, be sure to use a wood conditioner first--it helps the stain take much more smoothly.

We do have red oak treads on our staircase, pine balusters, and an ash banister. Getting it all the same tone was tricky, but it blends OK. The ash was the most difficult to stain, taking three or four coats to the oak's one or two, which, in turn, took at least two to match the pine.

    Bookmark   October 13, 2010 at 12:32PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
dabunch

FYI- I had seen a White Oak floor finished with waterbased polyurethane and it looked as light as Maple flooring. The veins in the wood weren't as prominent, but the floor was very pretty and light. Some flooring companies have samples so you can see what it looks like.

If I can remember correctly, we had pine doors and pine trim in our previous house. We had the painters stain them just a touch darker than natural. You almost couldn't see any stain. It looked really nice, but I got tired of the yellow/orange like color. It seems that Oak and pine turn a little more yellow/orange if you leave it natural or don't stain it dark enough.

I like both the white or the stained look, but recently I was wondering if a whitish/linen milk wash on pine doors and trim would look nice.
I saw this pine wall at Ikea that had a linen color milk wash stain with satin poly over it and it looked stunning.
I thought that a thin stain in off white with poly would give it a lighter look (for those of us who prefer natural or ligher wood), with virtually no further upkeep, and the wood wouldn't get the yellow/orange color). I wonder how paint would look next to that type of stain...
I think I'll try to experiment with it and see if I would use it when we build our next house.

PS-I'm noticing that the green homes around here seem to be going with natural wood (no stains), including the floors and the kitchen cabinets.
In light of that, I wonder if white or stained kitchen cabinets will be phased out as the homes go green...

    Bookmark   October 18, 2010 at 10:48AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
rudykan1_comcast_net

What is the best stain to finish pine doors to look like the oak trim I have?

    Bookmark   April 2, 2011 at 4:58PM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
Master Bedroom Floorplan Review
Hello, I am currently working on building a new house...
mary8153
Thinking about driveways
One of the few things my husband requests in our new...
mrspete
building a simple modern farm house on a budget
I am planning to build a simple modern looking farmhouse...
usalli
Please critique plan.
Please critique plan. Thank you!
einajr
It's March 2015: How is your build progressing?
Zorro-anyone can start one. :) Link to It's February...
autumn.4
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™