Need help picking low to mid range applainces

sycoreSeptember 23, 2012


I am trying to help my sister out that is moving into a home and needs all 4 kitchen appliances. Fridge, Oven, Dishwasher and Microwave. I usually research everything and give her a recommendation. She is on a budget, looking to spend no more than $4000 for Stainless Steel. Trying to research appliances will drive you crazy, as it seems no matter which brand there are problems.

I have never recommend an extended warranty in my life, but I think I will to her to get one for at least the Refrigerator. I don't know why the manufacture can not just have matching good, better, best packages.

Anyway, I have stuck to the budget brands and she likes the looks of the Frigidaire Gallery series, but the many problem with the ice makers and poor quality of Frigidaire budget brands in general, seems to rule it out.

I am left with LG and Samsung. How are Maytag or KitchenAid. Are they just higher end Frigidaires? Any recommendations? She might go with French doors and then just get an ice chest for the garage for her large family. How do they handle fingerprints, another of her pet peeves. Thanks for any info you can supply.

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo


Basically, the current CR survey results (of 61,000 CR members with newer fridges) show Whilrpool models to be the most reliable.

Maytag and kitchenaid are brands used by Whirlpool, not Frigidaire (which is actually an Electrolux subisidiary).

Whirlpool also makes some of the refrigerators that Sears sells under its Kenmore brand. The other primary Whirlpool Corp. brands for fridges are Whirlpool, Whirlpool Gold and Amana. Whirlpool bought Maytag/Amana after bad management nearly wrecked them over the last decade. (On the other hand, I've still got my vintage 1998 Maytag 2156. It met the 2001 Energy Star requirements and is barely less efficient than those meeting the current standards.) By the mid-2000s, Maytag and Amana had a deservedly terrible reputation for a while, enough so that it continues to poison the results of the Consumer Reports reliability surveys which go back 6 or seven years. Check out the link below for a recent extensive discussion of these brands in the context of bottom freezer fridges

Kitchenaid fridges are gussied up versions of the same thing that Whirlpool sells under its other brand names. Kitchenaid comes back with slightly less reliability basically because almost all of them come with ice-makers and a high proportion of them have through-the-door ice-makers and water dispensers. Ice-makers and water dispensers are the components that can be troublesome and account for a goodly proportion of defect complaints. This is true of all makers.

Again, check out the link below because it will lead you to other resources.

Tons of threads on these including low and high end. For basic dishwashers, I am partial to the basic Ascenta Bosch models. Look for sales on Columbus Day. It has a combination stainless and polypro tub and gets pretty high marks from CR. What I like is that they run relatively quickly. A lot of the Whirlpool and Frigidaire that I looked at recently had very long cycle times (like more than two hours). Do you have access to CR ratings?
Getting stainless steel exteriors usually adds a hundred bucks to the price, but holiday sales can help lower that cost a bit. (Pretty much true for all appliances, btw.)
Gas? Electric smoothtop? Coil burners? Induction is nice but may be pushing the budget. The least expensive one I've seen recently was Samsung's new NE695 freestanding stainless induction stove which was down to about $1250 at Best Buy over labor day weekend. IF the budget can accomodate that, then the next question is whether or not s your sister have much cookware already? Costco sells several sets of induction capable cookware for about $200.

Hard to give specific advice without knowing more about the kitchen but there are tons of postings here about microwaves. Any space constraints? Does it need to go on a shelf? Will it sit on a counter or cart? Are you looking for an OTR? You can really save a lot of money if you do not need an OTR. Better to get a inexpensive externally venting range hood and an inexpensive microwave.

EXTENDED WARRANTIES are only as good as the service companies to whom service is outsourced. Several of the national service companies have awful reputations. For a sense of how good or poor warranty service. Check out to see what warranty service can do to a manufacturer's reputation.

Here is a link that might be useful: Need a new refrigerator, any recommendations on which one?

    Bookmark   September 24, 2012 at 1:17AM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
Bluestar platinum vs Capital Culinarian
We are deciding on kitchen appliances for our upgrade...
essentials you can't live without in your front load washing machine?
I am trying to purchase a new washing machine for our...
Anyone have a Jenn-Air 48' range?
Hello, I was ready to buy a 48" DCS 5-burner w/griddle...
Bread baking in the Blue Star Range
We are in the process of building a new home and though...
New cooktop slightly smaller than old cutout in granite
I have a 36 " gas cooktop in my granite countertop...
Sponsored Products
Oriental Red Hand Knotted 5'X7' Wool & Silk Nepalese Rug H1860
BH Sun Inc
Urn Antique Bronze 28-inch to 48-inch Curtain Rod
$23.95 | Bellacor
Logico Mini Triple Linear Semi-Flushmount by Artemide
$1,735.00 | Lumens
Glory Baby Pink Wallpaper R1456, sample
Walls Republic
Contemporary Indoor/Outdoor Area Rug: Kas Rugs Rugs Multi Floral Tropics Multi
Home Depot
Digital Programmable Thermometer
$29.95 | FRONTGATE
Series 7 Armchair - Natural Veneer by Fritz Hansen
$1,221.00 | Lumens
33" Flue Extension for 36" Maestro Series Black Island Range Hood
Signature Hardware
People viewed this after searching for:
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™