Charcoal smoker - Temp gauge question

cdsolNovember 7, 2010

I've got a Brinkman Gormet Charcoal Smoker as a replacement to an identical one that finally rusted out. Don't know model number, but it's the vertically oriented tube with fire pit at bottom and water pan in the middle.

The lid has a thermometer marked "Warm-Ideal-Hot". The old lid is still OK, and for whatever reason, sometimes I use the old lid, sometimes the new one.

I'm getting ready to use it and I just noticed that the two thermometers differ widely. As a test, I removed them both and used aluminum foil to suspend them in the steam from a pot of boiling water. One of them barely came up to the "Ideal" and the other got almost into "Hot". Which one should I believe...assuming that the water steam should have been roughly 212 F?

Many thanks

Carl - Dallas TX

Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
Best Gas Grill
We are building a new home and looking to build an...
litlmikeyb
How long one can use Grill (Life time)
Hi, My previous owner left us Grand Turbo grill by...
ritholtz
What are your most useful appliances in outdoor kitchen
We are in the design stages for our outdoor grilling...
squwhat
how to remove paint stain from stainless steel bbq?
someone spilled what appears to be stain or paint on...
wantboost
lynx or dcs best prices?
I had posted this in the appliance section but this...
nolacls
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™