Fake mascara?

gellchomMarch 9, 2006

I love the Diorshow mascara I bought last summer, but it's expensive. So I ordered one from an Ebay retailer with a very good rating and lots of sales. It came today, and it looks a little different from the one I'm replacing. The markings on the tube and the little sticker at the end are a little different, the "CD" on the cap is blue instead of black, there are fewer turns to the screw top, and the brush itself looks a little smaller. It looks like a good quality mascara, and I found nothing on the web about counterfeit cosmetics, so I'm wondering if Dior just changed their packaging a little.

What do you think?

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

I would go to a reputable retailer, and see what they are selling. If the packaging has changed, it should match what you received from the ebay seller.

    Bookmark   March 9, 2006 at 8:30PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

Here's what I found out, in case anyone else is following this thread:
First I learned from Dior that they did indeed change their packaging.
Then I heard from the Ebay retailer. She checked with her supplier, and learned that the batch she bought is real Dior, but it was purchased in Poland, where both the formula and packaging are different. I don't care about the packaging, but I tried the mascara, and I don't like it. It looks okay when I put it on, but it is really strange when I wash it off -- it leaves black "lint" and lashes -- I hope not my real ones -- all over my face. The seller is very nice and said she would be happy to refund my money. No wonder she has a 99.9% positive rating!

    Bookmark   March 13, 2006 at 10:23PM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
Regular down vs. ultra lite down
Help, I live in the south where down is not part of...
twisted silver chain
When I was in Poland a friend gave me a silver chain...
where Cathy Daniels clothing sold...?
I have a hard time getting clothes to fit well &...
Facial Hair from upper lip
Hi All upper lip I have an embrassing problem with...
Skin Health Maintenance
Hi, I am 30 and need advice on my skin care/skin health...
Sponsored Products
Artificial Ranunculus Stems (Set of 12)
Hudson Valley Lighting | Chelsea Four Light Pendant
$964.00 | YLighting
Forever Green Art Preserved Triple Ball Topiary In 50
Beyond Stores
Indoor/ Outdoor Silk Rosemary Spiral Tree
Asteroid Table/Floor Lamp by Innermost
$400.50 | Lumens
Gus Modern | Wilson End Table - Quick Ship
Break Pathway Light by Vibia
$2,330.00 | Lumens
Sunforce Outdoor Lighting. Solar Motion Security Light with 60 LED
$34.99 | Home Depot
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™