How about polyethylene on the foundation wall

worthyFebruary 21, 2013

I received this question directly, but I prefer to answer it on the forum so it might be of use to others.

I live in climate zone 4 (non-marine). XPS rigid foam seems to be the most common recommendation for this area, but the cost has me continuing to research. Given that the air diffusion should happen inward, can I not put a polyethylene vapor barrier against the concrete foundation, and finish the walls with R13 FG batting and drywall? Polyethylene is only a slightly more impenetrable vapor barrier than 2" XPS, so mold should be no greater of a concern, right?

The perm ratings of 6 mil polyethylene, at .06 perms, and one inch of extruded polystyrene (XPS), at 1, are not even. close.

Six-mil polyethylene film is rated as impermeable to water vapour and one inch of XPS is classed as semi-permeable to water vapour. #

XPS and similar moisture-tolerant semi-permeable insulation materials are recommended for basements. They permit the inward movement of water vapour without being affected by it. By contrast, if you put poly on the walls, the water vapour may condense on the back of the poly and feed mould growth. (See Photo below.) One way builders were previously advised to avoid this was to leave the poly loose at the bottom of the wall and leave spaces under the baseplate so any water would run into the finished area and evaporate away. I can't imagine this was very successful.

In predominantly heating climates, the use of poly barriers on the warm side of the insulation was to prevent the winter problem of a moisture drive to the exterior above grade (warm moves to cold). However, in summer the drive reverses, especially in air-conditioned homes, leaving water vapour trapped in the insulation behind the poly.

The safest solution for basements in all but extremely cold climates is to use a moisture tolerant permeable insulation with no low perm barriers.

In your climate, as little as 3/4" XPS against the foundation wall may be effective to keep moisture from condensing in cold weather. Another approach is to use at least two inches of cheaper expanded polystyrene against the foundation wall.

To meet the International Energy Conservation Code minimums, you can add fibrous insulation between the studs, according to Building Science Corp. Because basements are also prone to bulk water leaks, many building experts, such as Martin Holladay, suggest keeping all fibrous insulation out of the basement.

Here is a link that might be useful: Building Science Corp.: Basements

This post was edited by worthy on Tue, Feb 26, 13 at 10:36

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
worthy

Moving this post to myself down the line.

But I can't help noting that various highly-trafficked so-called building/handyman forums persist in perpetuating practices long since discredited by building scientists. And none more common than the "poly on the wall, two-inches of space followed by batt-filled framing" basement finishing.

Just because you post the same stuff 26,000 times doesn't make it right!

    Bookmark   February 26, 2013 at 12:23PM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
basement flooring - tile or finished concrete
we're planning a reno that will include expanding and...
lmgch
Ductwork through joist question
Hi, I know this is possibly controversial...I understand...
NYcRavi
Walk-out basement design
Building a house in western Massachusetts -- it will...
Artemis_MA
Easier way to burst up concrete?
Since it seem I have to do some concrete busting work...
ravlegend
Basement Plans Thoughts?
Hello, Planning to finishing my basement and hoping...
NYcRavi
People viewed this after searching for:
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™